Blog

  • Shareholder Dispute? How a Business Valuation Expert Protects Your Interest

    Let me tell you about the mess I walked into last spring. A friend of mine, we’ll call him Dave (because that’s his name and he’d probably laugh at me being coy about it), called me at 11 pm on a Tuesday. His voice had that tight, reedy quality you hear right before someone either cries or throws something.

    His business partner of nine years had just announced he wanted out, and he wanted “his fair share.”

    Fair share. Two words that sound so reasonable until you realize nobody agrees on what they mean.

    Dave owned 45 percent of a specialty manufacturing company. His partner owned the rest. They’d built the thing from a rented garage and a lot of bad coffee. Now there were real customers, real equipment, real money. And suddenly, a real problem.

    Here’s the thing nobody tells you about shareholder disputes: they’re rarely about the business. They’re about people. Hurt feelings, old grudges, that one comment at a holiday party in 2019 that everyone pretends to have forgotten. The business just happens to be where the fight gets fought.

    Which is exactly why you need someone who doesn’t care about any of that.

    What a Business Valuation Expert Actually Does in a Shareholder Dispute

    Okay, quick primer. A business valuation expert, like the ones at Seattle Business Brokers Desk, figures out what your company is worth. Groundbreaking, I know. But in a dispute, that number becomes a weapon, a shield, or a peace treaty depending on how it’s used.

    Here’s what these folks bring to the table:

    • An independent number. Not the number you want. Not the number your partner wants. A defensible figure backed by methodology, market data, and documentation.

    • Credibility in negotiations. When your partner’s cousin who “knows finance” throws out a number, your expert can calmly dismantle it with actual evidence.

    • Court-ready testimony. If this thing ends up in front of a judge, you need someone who can explain complex financials to people who last took an accounting class in 1998.

    • A reality check. Sometimes the number is lower than you hoped. Better to hear it from an expert early than from a judge later.

    The best part? The expert has zero emotional investment. They don’t care that your partner borrowed your snowblower and never returned it. They care about cash flow, comparable sales, and discount rates.

    Why I Stopped Thinking I Could DIY This

    Full disclosure: I tried to handle Dave’s situation myself at first. I read some articles. I made a spreadsheet. I felt very smart for approximately 48 hours.

    Then his partner hired an actual valuation firm, and I realized my spreadsheet was the financial equivalent of a potato battery. The other side’s report was 60 pages. Mine was a Google Sheet with three tabs and a typo in the header.

    Pride is expensive, folks. Hire the expert.

    There’s also this subtle trap: in a dispute, whoever controls the narrative controls the outcome. If your partner’s expert says the business is worth X, and you show up with vibes and good intentions, you’ve already lost ground. A proper valuation report gives you a seat at the table instead of a spot in the audience.

    The Three Methods That Matter (and Why You Should Care)

    Valuation experts typically work with a few core approaches. You don’t need to master them, but knowing the names helps you ask better questions:

    1. Income approach. What future earnings is this business expected to generate, discounted back to today? This is the heavyweight champ for profitable companies.

    2. Market approach. What do similar businesses sell for? Straightforward in theory, tricky in practice because every business thinks it’s unique.

    3. Asset-based approach. What are the underlying assets worth? Common for holding companies or businesses with heavy equipment.

    Here’s the wild part: the choice of method can swing the final number by millions. Not because anyone’s cheating, but because businesses are complicated and value is genuinely a range, not a single point. A good expert explains the range and defends the reasoning. A bad one just picks the number that makes their client happy.

    What Happens When You Skip This Step

    Let me paint a picture. You and your partner can’t agree. You go to mediation. You each bring a lawyer and a number you pulled from thin air. The mediator sighs, visibly ages five years, and suggests you both get valuations done. Six months and a pile of legal fees later, you’re back where you started, except now everyone’s exhausted and the business has lost momentum.

    Bullet points of pain:

    • Delayed resolution means delayed money

    • Legal fees compound fast

    • Operational decisions stall while everyone’s distracted

    • Relationships (business and personal) sour beyond repair

    Get the valuation early. It costs less than you think and saves more than you can imagine.

    A Few Things I Wish I’d Known Sooner

    Some hard-won lessons from the Dave saga, which, for the record, ended with a mediated settlement both sides could live with:

    • Timing matters. Get the expert involved before positions harden. The longer the fight simmers, the more expensive the resolution.

    • Documentation is everything. Clean books, clear contracts, and organized records make valuations faster and cheaper. Chaos costs money.

    • The expert isn’t your advocate. They’re your translator. Let them be neutral. That’s their power.

    • Ask about court experience. Negotiation chops and testifying chops are different skills. You want both.

    The whole ordeal taught me something I now repeat to anyone who’ll listen: a business valuation expert isn’t a cost. It’s insurance for your ownership stake. Dave’s company survived. Not everyone’s does.

    So if you’re staring down a shareholder dispute, do yourself a favor. Skip the 11 pm panic calls and the potato-battery spreadsheets. Call an expert. Let them do the math while you keep your business running.

    Your future self will thank you. Probably with a much nicer spreadsheet.

  • Proof of Funds: The Simple Gate That Filters Out Time-Wasting Business Buyers

    I learned this lesson the hard way, and it cost me about six weeks of my life I will never get back.

    A few years ago I listed a property that I was sure would move fast. Nice lot, fair price, solid bones. The calls came in hot and heavy. One guy in particular was so enthusiastic. Called me three times in a day. Told me he could already picture his kids in the backyard. He wanted to walk the property that weekend.

    Then next weekend. Then a third time, this time with his brother-in-law who “knows a thing or two about foundations.” Six weeks of this. Six weeks of me rearranging my schedule, answering late night texts, and turning away other lookers because I figured we were practically at the closing table.

    When it came time to actually make an offer, the man went quiet. Radio silence. Then a text: “Working on getting the down payment together.” Translation? He never had it. He was window shopping with my time.

    I felt like a guy who spent three hours spotting someone at the gym only to watch them load the bar with the same weight they warmed up with. Frustrating does not even cover it.

    That is when I became a believer in proof of funds. Not as a weapon. As a filter. Here is why this one simple gate matters more than almost anything else you do early in a deal.

    What Proof of Funds Actually Means

    Proof of funds is straightforward. It is documentation showing a buyer has the money available to close. Think:

    • A recent bank statement (usually 30 to 60 days old)

    • A letter from a lender confirming a pre approval

    • A statement from a brokerage or investment account

    Notice what it is not: a promise, a maybe, or a story about a rich uncle who is “totally good for it.” Those are nice. They are also worth exactly nothing when the deadline hits.

    The Gate Does the Hard Work for You

    Here is the part people miss. Asking for proof of funds is not about being suspicious of everyone. It is about being respectful of your own calendar. Think of it like a bouncer at a club. The bouncer is not your enemy. He is the reason the dance floor is not crammed with people who did not pay.

    Once I started requiring it upfront, a funny thing happened. The tire kickers vanished. The serious buyers? Most of them had their paperwork ready before I even asked. They appreciated it. Real buyers want to know you are not wasting their time either.

    Three quick benefits:

    1. It cuts the dead weight immediately

    2. It signals you run a professional process

    3. It shortens the timeline from first call to closing

    How to Ask Without Being a Jerk

    You do not need to come in with a clipboard and a scowl. Keep it light. Something like: “Happy to set up a walkthrough. Before we do, can you send over a quick proof of funds? Just keeps things moving for both of us.” Nine times out of ten, nobody blinks. The one who gets offended? That was your answer, friend. That was always your answer.

    Bottom line: this gate is not fancy. It is not glamorous. It just works. Protect your time like you protect your training days. Both are limited, and both are yours.

  • SDE Multiple Calculation for Main Street Businesses: A Practical Walkthrough

    Let me tell you something I’ve learned from decades of training: numbers don’t lie, but they don’t tell the whole story either. Same goes for valuing a Main Street business. You can’t just eyeball it and hope for the best. I’ve seen too many folks make that mistake, and it stings worse than a missed rep on max-out day.

    So let’s talk about Seller’s Discretionary Earnings multiples. Real talk, no fluff.

    What SDE Actually Means (And Why It Matters)

    Think of SDE as the true earning power of a small business. It’s the number you get when you take net income, add back the owner’s salary, toss in some non-cash expenses like depreciation, and adjust for those one-time costs nobody talks about. The stuff that makes the business look leaner or fatter than it really is.

    Here’s the deal:

    1. Start with net income

    2. Add back owner compensation

    3. Add non-cash expenses (depreciation, amortization)

    4. Adjust for personal expenses run through the business

    5. Strip out one-time gains or losses

    Sounds simple, right? It’s not. That’s the trap.

    The Multiple Itself: Where Things Get Interesting

    Main Street businesses usually trade between 2x and 4x SDE. That’s your starting range. But here’s what nobody tells you at the seminars: the multiple is a moving target. It flexes based on things you can’t always quantify.

    Ask yourself these questions:

    • Does the business run without the owner chained to the register?

    • Are the customers loyal or just convenient?

    • What’s the growth trajectory, not just the historical average?

    • How transferable are the skills and relationships?

    I once watched a guy pay 4.5x for a business that looked golden on paper. Six months later, half the clients walked because they were loyal to the seller, not the shop. That multiple cratered faster than my ego after a bad posing routine. Lesson learned the hard way.

    A Practical Walkthrough: Crunching the Numbers

    Let’s say a local hardware store shows $180,000 net income. Owner takes $60,000 salary. Depreciation sits at $15,000. There’s a one-time legal expense of $5,000 from last year.

    Your SDE math:

    • Net income: $180,000

    • Owner salary: +$60,000

    • Depreciation: +$15,000

    • One-time legal: +$5,000

    • SDE: $260,000

    Now apply a 3x multiple. You’re looking at $780,000. At 2.5x, it drops to $650,000. See how the range shifts? That’s why you never lock in one number and call it a day.

    Red Flags That Mess With Your Multiple

    • Customer concentration. If one client is 40% of revenue, you’ve got a problem.

    • Declining foot traffic. Location matters more than ever.

    • Owner dependency. If the business falls apart when the owner takes a vacation, you’re buying a job, not a business.

    • Outdated systems. Manual bookkeeping in this day and age? Yikes.

    Wrapping It Up

    Valuing a Main Street business isn’t glamorous. It’s grunt work. But get it right and you build something solid. Get it wrong and you’ll feel it for years.

    Do the homework. Ask the ugly questions. Trust the math but verify the story behind it. That’s how you win in this game.

  • How to Verify a Buyer Can Get SBA Financing Before You Waste Months

    I once watched a deal die at month seven. Seven months of inspections, environmental reports, lease reviews, and enough paperwork to choke a copy machine. The buyer swore up and down that financing was locked. Spoiler alert: it was not. The bank pulled the plug two weeks before closing, and I was left standing in an empty parking lot wondering where my summer went.

    That experience taught me a lesson I now treat like gospel in commercial real estate. Before you invest serious time with any buyer, verify they can actually get SBA financing. Not “pre-qualified.” Not “the bank loves them.” Verified. Here is how I do it now, and how you can save yourself months of pain.

    Why SBA Deals Stall Out (And Why It Hurts the Seller)

    SBA loans are fantastic tools for buyers. They are also unforgiving on eligibility. The Small Business Administration has strict rules on business size, owner occupancy, credit history, and cash injection. A buyer can look rock solid on the surface and still get bounced for reasons nobody checked upfront.

    Here is the ugly truth from my side of the table:

    1. SBA lenders take 60 to 90 days to underwrite, sometimes longer

    2. Buyers often confuse “pre-qualification” with an actual commitment

    3. One credit blemish or undocumented income source can sink the whole file

    4. Sellers who wait find out too late that the buyer was never viable

    Step One: Ask for a Lender Pre-Approval Letter (Not a Pre-Qual)

    There is a big difference between these two documents. A pre-qualification is basically a lender saying “sure, you seem nice.” A pre-approval means the lender reviewed credit, financials, and tax returns. Ask for the letter directly from an SBA-approved lender. If the buyer cannot produce one, hit pause immediately.

    Step Two: Confirm the Buyer’s SBA Eligibility Basics

    You do not need to run a full audit, but you should confirm the big items:

    • Business size standards: Does the buyer’s business fall under SBA size caps for the industry?

    • Owner occupancy: For real estate deals, the buyer typically must occupy at least 51 percent of the property

    • Cash injection: Most SBA 7(a) deals require a 10 percent down payment from the buyer’s own funds

    • Credit and character: Lenders pull personal credit and review criminal and financial history

    A quick conversation with the buyer’s lender can confirm all of this in about fifteen minutes. Do it early.

    Step Three: Talk to the Lender Directly

    This step feels a little bold, but it works. Ask the buyer for permission to speak with their loan officer. Then ask three questions:

    1. Has this buyer submitted a complete application yet?

    2. What conditions remain open on the file?

    3. What is the realistic timeline to a commitment letter?

    If the loan officer hesitates on any of these, treat it as a red flag. Pros answer directly.

    Step Four: Require a Financing Contingency With Teeth

    Put a deadline in the purchase agreement. Something like 45 days for the buyer to deliver a written loan commitment. No commitment, no deal, and the earnest money stays put. This one clause has saved me more headaches than any other tool in my kit. It forces the buyer to move with urgency and protects you if they cannot deliver.

    Step Five: Watch for These Warning Signs

    • Buyer avoids sharing financial statements or tax returns

    • Lender name changes every time you ask

    • Timeline keeps slipping with vague excuses

    • Down payment “will come together later”

    • Buyer cannot explain basic SBA terms like guaranty or debenture

    Trust your gut. If something feels off, it probably is.

    The Bottom Line

    Time is the most expensive thing you own in a deal. Protect it. Verify financing early, verify it in writing, and verify it with the lender directly. Do that, and you will never again spend seven months babysitting a deal that was never going to close.